Welcome to Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery
Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery is a gem located in New Paltz, NY, offering a delightful seafood experience. Renowned for its fresh catch and flavorful dishes, it serves a diverse menu that includes swordfish chili, cod tacos, and a must-try shrimp basket. Patrons rave about the quality and preparation, highlighting the light, crunchy batter and exceptional flavors. The casual, friendly atmosphere is complemented by knowledgeable staff, making it a perfect spot for a tasty meal. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or savoring a sit-down dinner, Gadaleto's promises an outstanding seafood experience worth returning for.
Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery: Reviews & Ratings
Omg! Let me start with.. THEY HAVE THE BEST COOKIES EVER!!!!!! I ate one b4 my meal, and took 2 to go! We ordered the swordfish chili, the cod fish tacos with grit cakes, raw clams, and beer battered cod and fries! Everything was outstanding! I can’t wait to go back! The staff was very nice, friendly, and helpful. The food is so fresh and served nice and hot! You order at the counter and they bring your food out!
Best seafood meal I've had in decades. A big hunk of fresh, fresh haddock, cooked to perfection and served hot. It was accompanied by sweet potato fries, again, perfectly prepared. And also a generous serving of crunchy cole slaw, in a take-home container. My companion shared one of her scallops with me: also perfectly fresh, tenderly prepared. Six stars.
The shrimp and grit cakes were awesome!! Blackened salmon and whole belly clams were great too!
Gadaleto's is the best fresh fish in the Hudson Valley period. Great staff that is very knowledgeable. I always go there for tuna and salmon for making Sushi!
Had the best shrimp basket here!! The batter was lite and crunchy,the tarter was delicious!! Fried to perfection!! Casual dining, highly recommended
Atmosphere is relaxed. Everyone is extremely nice. I will definitely come back. Food was good. I had crab and fries. Hubby had lobster bisque and fish. Definitely recommend
Been wanting to try this place for some time now and it did not disappoint! Family owned and operated. I got the Lobster Bake with Fries and Crab Cake Appetizer. Absolutely phenomenal food and very fresh! Will be coming here again with friends.
I have bought seafood at Gadaleto’s before and it’s always been excellent but today was my first time dining in. My friends comment says it all: “I live on an island and I can’t get seafood this good there.” There is counter service and take out for now and a spacious clean dining room for eating in. You have a choice of disposable or reusable silverware. All of the food came in generous portions and was truly delicious. The bathroom was clean although it could benefit from a few minor repairs. We will definitely be back!
Location
-
246 Main St #1, New Paltz, NY 12561, United States Hotline: +1 845-255-1717
Welcome to the vibrant world of Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of New Paltz, NY. Located at 246 Main St #1, this establishment offers more than just fresh seafood; it delivers an experience woven with culinary passion and community warmth.
As you step inside, you are greeted by friendly faces and the inviting aroma of the ocean. The atmosphere is casual yet bustling, embodying a true seafood market vibe where you can order at the counter and enjoy remarkable dishes brought to your table. From the moment you sink your teeth into their offerings, it is clear that Gadaleto's prioritizes freshness—each item prepared with care that’s evident in every bite.
Let’s delve into some customer favorites. Vicki M can't help but rave about their renowned cookies, declaring them to be the best ever. Pairing these sweet delights with a savory meal, she highlights the swordfish chili and cod fish tacos served alongside delectable grit cakes. The shrimp baskets, praised by Dayna Mudge, are fried to crunchy perfection, while Jeff lauds the shrimp and grit cakes, as well as the flavor-packed blackened salmon.
For the true seafood aficionados, Randy Finney emphasizes that Gadaleto's serves the freshest fish in the Hudson Valley. Whether you’re looking for top-notch tuna for sushi or succulent salmon, the knowledgeable staff is always ready to recommend the best seafood that the market has to offer.
One bite of their perfectly cooked haddock sends Maggie Boys into a culinary time machine, reminiscing about seafood meals from decades past. Paired with expertly prepared sweet potato fries and a generous helping of crunchy cole slaw, each dish sings with freshness and flavor. It's no surprise that Gadaleto's has garnered such loyal patrons.
In a culinary landscape where freshness and quality can be elusive, Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery stands out as a bastion of excellence. With its commitment to serving the best seafood and an inviting environment, it's not merely a meal, but a culinary journey waiting to unfold. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by, indulge in the diverse menu, and experience why so many are singing Gadaleto's praises!